[GSBN] The EU wants 5% strawbuildings by 2020 says the Economist..

[Jacob Deva Racusin]

Valentina,

I appreciate your perspective.  This is a conversation that has come up 
a number of times in our courses and conversations with our colleagues - 
namely, the roll of agribusiness in providing feedstock for our 
construction.  I think 'greenwashing' may be a bit strong, when I 
compare to the claims of the concrete and foam industries as being 
'green'.  That said, the impacts must be considered, and the benefits of 
using straw in regards to deep ecological and social impact should not 
be overstated if the source of straw is not being considered.  We have 
access to straw that is grown from medium- and small-scale farms, which 
come closer to the higher potential of working with this material.  It 
is very analogous to working with wood -the same framing member can come 
from a local sawyer practicing sustainable silviculture, or from a 
genetically-engineered clear-cut plantation pine shipped across the world.

 From data I've seen, even industrial straw is a fraction of the 
embodied carbon of other common forms of insulation, so context is 
relevant when evaluating materials for deep impact. You make an 
especially good point about the danger of introducing this material to 
industrial scale, and losing more of the benefits/exacerbating the 
liabilities in favor of snapping the technology into the mold of 
industrial housing/building development.  We would do well as a 
community not to lose sight of the importance of scale, and as you 
mention the relevance of the social benefits of working with straw. At 
the same time, access to a much larger market and making the technology 
available to many more people is an arguable net gain, even if there is 
a sacrifice for environmental and social impact in production - again, 
compared to the alternatives.  I think there is room for both, and as 
long as we continue to engage in the debate, I have confidence that 
we'll continue to move the ball further down the field.

Cheers,
Jacob

-- 
Jacob Deva Racusin
Co-Owner
New Frameworks Natural Design/Build

Author, The Natural Building Companion
Chelsea Green Press, 2012

(802) 782-7783
jacob at newframeworks.com
http://www.newframeworks.com

On 12/18/13, 12:43 PM, valentina maini wrote:
> Martin, John, Caroline, and all
> as Herbert Gruber recently suggested on Leonardo group,  this article 
> maybe very well connected with the EU funded 
> ( eco-innovation) investigation on @Modcell ....based in the UK and 
> with BathUniversity support
>
> I personally got in touch with the founder of this panels in 2011 and 
> met with professionals here in spain that are collaborating in this EU 
> funded program of analysis and implementation of this "patent" 
> strawbale panels....i've seen fantastic software and marketing tools 
> they were presenting at Eco event in London 2011
>
> From my point of view and with very recent experiences on professional 
> development of strawbale in Spain i think and see this article as a 
> call for action to present the real value of strawbale and strawbale 
> network..that goes, in my view, very much beyond the "simple" energy 
> efficiency issue...
> and i very important reminder for all that straw is not at all a 
> really safe for the environment product...since is a byproduct of one 
> of the most contaminated  human "fabric"...as industrial agriculture 
> ...as very well reminds Luc Foissac in is great book on strawbale...
>
> from my point of view...The very big risk/reality at the moment is 
> that straw is used very much as a "simple" greenwash.....
>  and even if  i really celebrate the greenwash for what it means in 
> terms of getting rid of toxic materials...i think and personally value 
> much more the social innovation related to strawbale... the ability of 
> people and networks to create opportunity and solutions....
>
> what is happening is just "business as usual" with a more 
> eco-material... what the strawbale network gave me  me is much much 
> more than simple "strawbale tech"... i learned.... thank to you 
> all.... the value and the tools to innovate and collaborate and manage 
> uncertainty.... and adapt and always look for the best solution for 
> people, planet...and even profit...
>
> and personally i'm really convinced that the risk for environment and 
> quality (equality) in our society is so big.....,  that is not enough 
> anymore to "change" material... and hope that the strawbale network 
> (that i value for itself) can make a huge step and show the world that 
> strawbalers are bringing much more to community and economy that a 
> "simple" prefab panel for passive house... a huge step to defend as 
> the real value the mission and vision of all the pioneers in strawbale 
> .... at least this is how i see you all ...
>
> hope my english is good enough...and...my mind is getting clear on 
> this issue just in this lasts months... so hope this comments are of 
> some interest for you ;-)
>
> best regards to you all, valentina
> Valentina Maini
> italy-spain
>
>
> This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and 
> intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they 
> are addressed. Use, disclosure, distribute, print or copy of this 
> communication is prohibited by law. If you received this email in 
> error please notify the sender and then delete it.
>


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.sustainablesources.com/pipermail/gsbn/attachments/20131218/b74e5a11/attachment.htm>